The last months have seen an extremely divisive election in the US. Its been painful to watch a country with such a history of leadership and an exemplar of a western democracy tear itself apart. The election has been “called” but it is worth noting that many Americans didn’t get the outcome they wanted and some even feel like they were cheated out of a rightful win.
A friend of mine voted for Donald Trump. I wouldn’t have but I didn’t have a vote. He’s a good person. In the days leading up to the election he posted a link to an op-ed that presented some reasons to vote for Donald Trump. I was interested to read it to better understand that perspective. I was intrigued by the note but disagreed strongly with much of what was said. I wondered for a while if it was worth responding given the election is over and I am a Canadian. In the end I felt it was worth writing down my thoughts not least because the article emphasized the importance of having a free exchange of ideas. It has also been bugging me and this blog is supposed to be a venue for me to get things out and hopefully, leave them behind. As was the case with the op-ed, I am giving my opinion and may be as subject to confirmation bias as the author was but here goes. I am doing it because we need to speak up regularly or we will all just go into our own little social media echo chambers.
One of the first points he makes is about libertarianism. I get that. I am inclined to think there are areas that the government shouldn’t be involved in. My line might be a bit different than his but I agree wholeheartedly that the government has no role in legislating morality. I don’t believe the government has any role in deciding who can get married, who you worship (or don’t). I also don’t think the government should legislate on abortion. That doesn’t make me pro-abortion but makes me pro-choice. Its not my place to tell others what to choose. So we start with some common ground.
I also think that he makes a good point about the Democratic Party. The US is more conservative on average than Canada is. The policy proposals of some Democrats are making many Republicans significantly uncomfortable. This is one of the problems with a two party system. The increased polarization in Canada is propping up the Liberals which drives some on the right in Canada nuts but that’s a topic for another post. There is no mid-point option in the US. The primary process to select candidates means you get more extreme candidates than might be ideally electable. If you look at the election results in the US, the Republicans fared remarkably well. Many Republican inclined voters chose what they thought was the lesser of two evils, held their noses and voted Trump. I wouldn’t have but I don’t think they were all “deplorables.”
Race
That is, however, one of the last points of agreement we had. The author says: “I fundamentally reject the idea that America is a racist country. In fact, I think America is the least racist country in the history of the world.” This is, in my view at best naïve and at worst delusional. Perhaps part of the difference is semantics (is the country racist or are some of the people in it racists) but it is clear that racism remains an issue across the globe. There are definitely countries in world where there is more equality than in the US but everyone has issues. The examples highlighted as evidence of a lack of racism is that Asian men make more money than other racial groups. That can’t be true in a “hopelessly racist country” can it? This is a perfect example of the misuse of statistics. How can you argue that high earning for Asian men is a reflection of the lack of racism but the lower than average earnings of Hispanics and Blacks are not a reflection of racial inequality. This is the epitome of confirmation bias or the purposeful misrepresentation of statistics to make the point you want to make. Median (not average) Asian household incomes are higher than others in the US. But median Black households are a third lower than the national median and Hispanic households are are 17% lower. That is not to say that Asians have it great. Asians have the highest level of income inequality in the US. Some are doing very well but many still are among the lowest earners. Many factors contribute to this difference in incomes but if you are going to tout one group as evidence of the lack of racism you can’t ignore the other outcomes and say they don’t have anything to do with racism.
He also highlights immigration as evidence that of a lack of racism because people are choosing the US and taking real risks to get there. In this case he is conflating both illegal and legal immigration. Part of the reason the US is getting lots of immigration is related to real economic opportunity. It is also due to convenience. If Canada was below the US instead of above it, there would be a significantly larger number of people trying to cross the border into Canada. Its worth noting that that there are large numbers of (primarily racial minorities) people trying to cross the border from the US into Canada which is also a significant political issue here. Europe is getting flooded with migrants because of its proximity to North Africa.
It is also important to note that some of the legal and illegal immigrants are leaving horrific conditions to try to find somewhere, anywhere, that’s better. That is setting a pretty low standard. One hopes that we as nations aspire to be better than just a bit better than some of the abysmal failed states that people are flocking out of.
The US does take in a large number of immigrants which does undeniably suggest that there is some attractiveness there. But on a per capita basis many countries, including Canada, take in more immigrants than the US does. Some of those differences will be due to policy differences but culture and living conditions are important here.
Reparations may or may not be an appropriate approach to achieving equality but denying the difference in opportunity and safety is simply putting your head in the sand. It could also just be unconscious bias. Privilege is real. If you haven’t had the experience you might not understand the disadvantage. Its not universal. Non-whites are more likely to see the advantage of being white. There are also whites who are disadvantaged. But the relative disadvantage and treatment is clearly affected by race. Talk to a person of colour about their lived experience and you will have your eyes opened – as relevant for Canadians as Americans. All of that and I haven’t talked about some of the issues that have drawn a lot of attention in the US and are indisputably race related.
I’ve had people say that the fact that Obama was President shows an absence of racism. First, there were very many Americans who didn’t vote for him and some of them didn’t simply because he was black. Ted Cruz was born in Canada. You heard a lot less about that than you did about Obama’s birth and he actually was born in the US. Second, there are circumstances that some people of colour will succeed DESPITE their disadvantages not because racism doesn’t exist – see the income statistics above again.
There are many Republicans who understand and acknowledge that racism exists. The disagreement is how best to address it. I would argue that Trump is a racist or at least that he was willing (keen even) to leverage racial divisions to his own advantage. This is not a Republican position, it is a Trump one.
Cancel Culture
The author is correct that we have become too quick to shout down ideas that disagree with ours – I am hopeful that this is a respectful disagreement. We might disagree on where the line is – I believe that we have an obligation to call out hate. There is bias in the media – on both sides of the political spectrum. Its easy to get to the fact that your ideas are being edited more than those of others but cancel culture is not a uniquely Democrat phenomenon. An American friend told a story about his Republican friend getting spit on while observing a right wing vote protest. He was wearing a mask. The intolerance of opposing views has to stop but I’m not sure this is a one sided issue and, frankly, as an outside observer, Donald Trump is one of the worst at attacking those that disagree with him.
COVID
COVID has been a profound global challenge. It has been difficult to strike a balance between ongoing economic activity and preventing the uncontrolled spread. I am not an infectious disease specialist but there seems to be some credence to the argument that the federal government in the US has mismanaged the fight against COVID. At the very least the politicization of the wearing of masks is unbelievable. There hasn’t been a national lockdown as far as I can see. There have been differences in state level closures because most of the decisions are the responsibility of the states. There have been Republican governed states that have been more aggressive than other states but there has been some degree of party line and this is largely due to the tone set by the President. He has consistently downplayed the threat of the virus for political gain. Ignoring that and saying that Biden will impose a lockdown (which as I understand he can’t) despite his assertions that he won’t is political hackery on par with those called out earlier in the article.
China did lie or at least withhold information in the early days. But this administration also lied and misled.
“While America has had many struggles, our national COVID death rate, per capita, is lower than many European democracies.” I suppose it depends on how you define “many.” I looked at an American source (Johns Hopkins University) which has the United States at the 13th highest per capita death rate in the world – behind Belgium, Spain, and the United Kingdom. There are a couple of tiny principalities but small samples make them moot.
China
“There’s a true battle over who will dominate the 21st century around the globe. Will it be China, with their lack of basic human rights, their trampling of free speech values, and their derogation of freedom of religion and the free exchange of ideas on the internet,”
I agree that China is attempting to become a dominant power in the world. We need to put a stake in the ground and stand up for what’s right.
“Donald Trump is the most aggressive confronter of China in my lifetime.” I couldn’t disagree more. Donald Trump has been silent on anything except the trade imbalance. There have been multiple opportunities to stand up to China (the Uighers, Hong Kong) when it comes to human rights and freedom of speech. The Trump administration has been the least vocal of any in my memory. This is true in cases of abuses in other countries too. The Trump administration has imposed tariffs on China (which mostly costs Americans money) in an effort to re-balance trade. The Republicans have been historically the party recognizing the benefits of trade. In this case the only confronting this administration has done is on trade and that has been largely unsuccessful. It could also be argued that the Trump administration has done exactly the same thing to other Western democracies (see Canada among others) so its hard to argue that the little bit of standing up he has done is relative to correcting bad behaviour relative to human rights or free speech.
Canada detained Meng Wanzhou at the request of the US administration. This is an influential Chinese national who is accused of bypassing the sanctions against Iran. The Chinese have since arbitrarily detained two Canadians and taken significant trade action against Canada in retaliation. We did it because it was the right thing to do and upheld the rule of law. Donald Trump said he was willing to trade the legal action in a negotiation for a trade deal. That hung Canada out to dry. That’s hardly a principled position of moral leadership. That’s pandering.
Supreme Court
I agree that expanding the supreme court would be a bad thing. It would undermine the role of the court. That said, I would argue that the about face the Republicans have taken with respect to confirmations in an election year were also a blow to the foundation of democratic principles. Neither outcome looks good on America.
American Exceptionalism and Capitalist Democracy
America has been a beacon of leadership in the world for the past century. That is hard to deny. As a Canadian I would argue that we’ve also been a positive influence but we simply don’t have the economic, military, or population might to play at the same level. American has been admired (and feared). I understand, if don’t always agree with the concept of American exceptionalism. I will say though that Donald Trump (not Republicans but this administration) has significantly eroded that moral leadership. He hasn’t stood up to dictators or bad actors in the world. If anything he’s cozied up to them. He left the Paris Accord. He left the Iran Nuclear Agreement. He’s waged political battles around the world. It goes on. If it was one or two of them you could chalk it up to policy differences. In truth, I agree with Trump about the United Nations. Its paid for in large part by the Americans and the countries with vetoes behave badly with impunity. But there has been a significant push towards disengagement and self interest -Trump and not America. In sum, however, it has undermined the ability of American to be a force for good in the world. Donald Trump has singlehandedly undermined American exceptionalism and global leadership.
As for democracy, we are witnessing a farce in the days before and after the election. All Republicans except Trump made gains in this US election. The attacks on the credibility of the election are unfathomable except to be the desperate flailing of a politician who has lost his people. Undermining democracy like this is unbecoming and is, frankly, making the US a laughingstock around the world. Add this to the process of gerrymandering (which disproportionately disenfranchises people of colour – see racism above) and the US is hardly advancing the cause of democracy in the broader world. We expect and hope for more leadership from the country.
Now, as I’ve reached the end of my rant I feel better. I don’t expect you (or anyone frankly) to read to the end (or even start) but I had to get it off my chest. We miss the America that leads in the world – even if we don’t always agree with it. Donald Trump took that away.